Why the Insurance Industry Is Facing a Generational Leadership Gap?

The insurance industry faces a generational leadership gap because its entry level has thinned out, not because its senior ranks are unusually old. Federal data makes the point clearly. About 4 percent of people working in insurance carriers and related activities are aged 20 to 24, against nearly 9 percent across all US industries. That leaves roughly six workers aged 55 and over for every one aged 20 to 24, compared with under three to one economy wide. At the same time, automation is removing the entry jobs where underwriting and claims judgment used to be learned. This article covers the size of the gap and why it is widening. It also covers how the gap differs across the four parts of the insurance value chain, and what employers can do now.

How Big Is the Insurance Leadership Gap?

The figures below come from the Bureau of Labor Statistics Current Population Survey, 2025 annual averages.

Group

Total Employed Aged 55 and Over Aged 20 to 24 Median Age
Insurance carriers and related activities 2.97 million 736,000 120,000

44.0

Insurance carriers

1.55 million 366,000 50,000 43.9
Agencies, brokerages, and related activities 1.42 million 369,000 70,000

44.2

All US industries

163.5 million 38.0 million 14.3 million

42.1

Two readings matter here.

At the senior end, insurance looks only slightly older than the wider economy. Workers aged 55 and over make up about 25 percent of insurance employment against roughly 23 percent across all industries. That difference alone would not create a crisis.

The young end tells a different story. Workers aged 20 to 24 are about 4 percent of insurance employment. Across all industries they are close to 9 percent. Insurance has less than half the share of early-career workers that the rest of the economy carries. That shortfall grows every year it continues.

That is what makes this a leadership problem rather than a staffing problem. Leaders come from the bottom of the pyramid ten to twenty years later. A narrow base today becomes a thin bench of directors and officers in the next decade.

Why Is the Gap Widening Now?

Three forces are working at once.

The Retirement Curve Is Already Cresting

Some 208,000 people working in insurance carriers and related activities are 65 or older, and another 528,000 are between 55 and 64. Those departures are not a forecast. They are scheduled.

The agency side carries more of this weight at the very top. Among agencies, brokerages, and related activities, 8.3 percent of workers are 65 or older. At carriers the figure is 5.8 percent.

Automation Is Removing the Training Ground

This is the piece most talent plans miss. BLS projects employment of insurance underwriters to fall 3 percent from 2024 to 2034, and claims adjusters, appraisers, examiners, and investigators to fall 5 percent. BLS attributes both to technology, including automated underwriting software and tools that estimate damage from photographs.

Now look at how the openings arise. BLS expects about 8,200 underwriter openings and 21,600 claims openings each year. All of them come from replacing people who move to other work or leave the workforce. Growth contributes nothing.

Those roles were where people learned to price risk, read a loss run, and hold a difficult conversation with a policyholder. Automating the routine work is sound business. It also removes the training path that produced chief underwriting officers. Few firms have put anything in its place.

Analytical Roles Are Growing Instead

BLS projects much faster growth for actuarial and data-focused work over the same decade. Those roles are valuable, but they build different judgments. A strong pricing modeler may still not be ready to run a book, manage producers, or carry authority on a disputed claim.

How Does the Gap Differ Across the Insurance Value Chain?

The gap is not uniform. Each segment loses something different when a leader leaves, so insurance talent planning works better segment by segment than industry wide.

Segment

Who Leads Where the Gap Shows Why It Is Hard to Fill
Retail agency and brokerage Principals, sales managers, producers holding books Owners near retirement with thin internal successors

Ownership transfer needs capital, client trust, and a trained buyer

Carrier

Chief underwriting officers, claims, product, and finance leaders Middle management between technical staff and the executive suite Calls for judgment built across soft and hard markets
MGA and wholesale Program leaders holding binding authority and profit responsibility Few people who can run underwriting and distribution together

Entrepreneurial and technical skill rarely sit in one person

Reinsurance

Treaty underwriters, analytics leaders, client executives The smallest candidate pool of the four

Global relationships and analytical depth take years to build

The Retail and Agency Side Feels It First

Agency data shows how close this is. The 2022 Agency Universe Study put the average age of agency principals at 54, with 17 percent aged 66 or older. Zeldis Research conducted it for Future One, a collaboration that includes the Big “I”. The 2024 edition found 1 in 3 agencies expecting an ownership change within five years.

Liberty Mutual’s 2023 Agency Growth Study surveyed more than 1,100 agency team members, including over 450 principals and owners. It found 40 percent of principals were older than 60, and 20 percent were older than 65. Half expected a major ownership change within ten years.

Here is the part that connects to hiring. More than eight in ten agencies report having a perpetuation plan, yet those plans usually center on children and family. In the 2022 study, principals named a lack of available talent as the leading obstacle to their agency’s future ownership. The plan exists. The successor often does not.

Why Is Insurance Leadership Harder to Replace Than Most?

Because the judgment is earned across cycles rather than taught in a course. An underwriting leader who has only worked in a soft market has never had to hold price while competitors give ground. A claims leader who has not managed a catastrophe response has not been tested at scale.

Relationships add another layer. On the retail side, the book often follows the person. In wholesale and reinsurance, carrier and cedent relationships took years to earn and do not transfer with a title change.

That combination is why a vacancy at this level stays open for months. It also explains why the obvious internal candidate is often not ready.

What Can Employers Do Now?

Waiting for the market to supply finished leaders is not a plan. These steps work.

  1. Map exposure by role, not by headcount. List the positions where one departure would cost you clients, authority, or reserve judgment. Rank them by how close the holder is to retiring.
  2. Rebuild the training path on purpose. If automation removed the entry roles that taught judgment, replace them with rotations, file reviews, and mentored decision authority. Judgment has to be practiced somewhere.
  3. Start perpetuation earlier and look past family. Internal transfer takes years of training and funding. Formal succession planning and career pathing turns intent into a schedule.
  4. Write the successor profile before the vacancy. Name the authority, lines, and cycle experience the next leader needs. A clear position profile keeps a search focused on the few who qualify.
  5. Recruit across segments and regions. A carrier underwriting leader can often run an MGA book, and a wholesale executive may strengthen a retail brokerage. Insisting on the same background shrinks a pool that is already small.
  6. Reach people who are not applying. Qualified insurance leaders are employed and busy. Retained executive search exists to approach them directly and privately.

Segment knowledge shortens all of this, since the right candidate for a program business rarely looks like the right candidate for a reinsurance desk. That distinction sits at the center of insurance executive search.

Final Thoughts

The generational leadership gap in insurance is measurable. It is driven by a missing base more than a bulge at the top. Federal data shows early-career workers at roughly half their share of the wider economy. It also shows six workers aged 55 and over for every one aged 20 to 24. Meanwhile the entry roles that once trained leaders are shrinking under automation. On the retail side, most agencies have a perpetuation plan while naming talent as the obstacle to using it.

None of that is fixed by posting a job when someone retires. It is fixed by naming your exposure, training judgment on purpose, and starting searches before the seat is empty. The Carlisle Group has recruited across carriers, brokerages, MGAs, and program business for three decades. Those searches run from underwriters and claims staff to the C-suite. If you can name the roles that would hurt most to lose, we can help you plan the bench before you need it.

Related Posts